Online group decision-making - 08/04/2020 11:10 EDT

Állapot: Closed
Díj: $1000
Beérkezett pályamű: 58
Nyertes: Rsquare Web Studio

Winner

A verseny összegzése

How can we improve online decision-making to support communities or small towns of hundreds of people, to cities of a million people. The goal is to make it easier for online groups to make more rational decisions.

Design (not implement) an online app to allow 1000+ people to make the best possible decisions on a wide variety of topics.

* Focus most on improving the decision & voting methods (not the style).

* Draw the user-interface. (Keep it simple, not fancy, grey-scale.)

* Describe the method of operation / data-flow in drawings and/or text. (Text can go in comments.)

Maybe improve on the decision & voting methods in these examples:
(You may have to copy & paste the links.)

https://www.choosewithreason.com/procon#page=request&link=U2ebQqwbqbcE4SmT9V3Tftg8yBbBSw8mgXf1BLlvFKWuEGy826

https://www.choosewithreason.com/autocomplete#page=question&link=07CPZ6KFprXg9QSl5MEZXaQ1wgh6Az0oOY1kHymXyj5aavHsi2

Ajánlott készségek

Winner

Tegyen közzé egy hasonló versenyt

Munkaadói értékelés

“@cehravi won the contest on 25 April 2020”

chadbrower, United States.

A verseny legjobb pályaművei

velectico India

1
Rsquare Web Studio India

1
MAGICMACC United States

0
AuPial Bangladesh

0
kinjalrajput2515 India

0
AuPial Bangladesh

0
rkdesi Bangladesh

0
KreateKat India

0
akandbharat2050 India

0
WebCraft111 Bangladesh

0
sirajkhan1992 India

0
WebCraft111 Bangladesh

0
kdmedev Philippines

0
WebCraft111 Bangladesh

0
WebCraft111 Bangladesh

0
WebCraft111 Bangladesh

0

További pályaművek

Nyilvános pontosítófelület

velectico
- 3 év telt el
Congratulations Ravi R. !
- 3 év telt el
WebCraft111
- 3 év telt el
Please review my all design #46 , #47 , #58 , #59 , #60 , #66 , #71 and let me know your thoughts. If you want any change or Update please feel free to inform me. Your valuable suggestions are most welcome. I will revise it until your final satisfaction. Thank you.
- 3 év telt el
1. MAGICMACC
  - 3 év telt el
  Best of luck :)
  - 3 év telt el
MAGICMACC
- 3 év telt el
Best of luck to all!
- 3 év telt el
MAGICMACC
- 3 év telt el
Hey there Chad, When you get chance, Please Rate and Comment on the design proposals and structural voting ideas I have given. Really Hoping you find them appealing Chad, Kind Regards #31 #37 #38 #39 #40 #41 #45 #50
Cheers!
- 3 év telt el
A verseny kiírója:
- 3 év telt el
I hope that everyone has had an opportunity to consider some new approaches to group decisions, and expand your ideas of how we can organize society.
- 3 év telt el
1. MAGICMACC
  - 3 év telt el
  Send me a private message if you have any questions on the designs! Regards
  - 3 év telt el
2. WebCraft111
  - 3 év telt el
  Please review my all design #46 , #47 , #58 , #59 , #60 , #66 , #71 and let me know your thoughts. If you want any change or Update please feel free to inform me. Your valuable suggestions are most welcome. I will revise it until your final satisfaction. Thank you.
  - 3 év telt el
A verseny kiírója:
- 3 év telt el
Hello all, and thank you for sharing your ideas! There are now nearly 100 submissions, so it will take several days to select a winner.
- 3 év telt el
1. MAGICMACC
  - 3 év telt el
  awesome!
  - 3 év telt el
2. KreateKat
  - 3 év telt el
  Good luck in your selection and let me know if you have any questions . Would be happy to upload any follow up requests on dropbox or something similar.
  
  And good luck to everybody else too !
  - 3 év telt el
akandbharat2050
- 3 év telt el
Hello Contest Holder, I have submitted my Entry #72 just now, please do consider it before making a final decision.
Thank You.
- 3 év telt el
1. akandbharat2050
  - 3 év telt el
  I have focused more on newer and interesting decision making and voting methodology and it could just be what you are looking for.
  - 3 év telt el
Rsquare Web Studio
- 3 év telt el
Sir, please provide feedback on #64 , #65
- 3 év telt el
WebCraft111
- 3 év telt el
Please check and provide feedback for my design #46 , #47 , #58 , #59 , & #60 . Thank you.
- 3 év telt el
KreateKat
- 3 év telt el
Still working. I will upload findings of my research before time ends !
- 3 év telt el
MAGICMACC
- 3 év telt el
Hey Chad, When ya get a chance check my latest entry #56
Cheers
- 3 év telt el
MAGICMACC
- 3 év telt el
Please Rate and Comment on the design proposals and structural voting ideas I have given. Really Hoping you find them appealing Chad, Kind Regards #31 #37 #38 #39 #40 #41 #45 #50 .

Cheers!
- 3 év telt el
Rsquare Web Studio
- 3 év telt el
Sir, please provide feedback on #42
- 3 év telt el
WebCraft111
- 3 év telt el
Please check and provide feedback for my design #46 , #47 . Thank you.
- 3 év telt el
MAGICMACC
- 3 év telt el
Dear CH, Please help us by rating (Staring) ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️our entries, to let us know how good our designs are from what/where you want from us. Cheers
- 3 év telt el
CreativeKaif
- 3 év telt el
#35
- 3 év telt el
Rsquare Web Studio
- 3 év telt el
Sir, please provide feedback on #33
- 3 év telt el
sirajkhan1992
- 4 év telt el
Sir, please check and provide feedback #14 #13
- 4 év telt el
A verseny kiírója:
- 4 év telt el
I'm only leaving comments on entries that offered some new decision & voting methods. I'm not commenting on entries that just re-styled the example website.
- 4 év telt el
1. SrinivasUi
  - 4 év telt el
  Sir, please check the link in the comment section in my entry for flow of UX design
  - 4 év telt el
2. SrinivasUi
  - 4 év telt el
  my Sincere Apology Sir, You right sir I re-styled your example website just 20% of the User interface were created in my entry and the remaining 80% is completely based UX so please check the comment that i provide a link in it that will give you an idea about voting and decision making .....hope you like it..
  - 4 év telt el
KarimSaif9
- 4 év telt el
sir
Do you need to design an app? And the web?
- 4 év telt el
SrinivasUi
- 4 év telt el
sir please check the #27
- 4 év telt el
A verseny kiírója:
- 4 év telt el
Also please consider that some users will abuse the system to try to influence the result, many users will decide irrationally, and most users will be lazy.
- 4 év telt el
1. SrinivasUi
  - 4 év telt el
  sir please check the #27 we need your valuable feedback from you :)
  - 4 év telt el
A verseny kiírója:
- 4 év telt el
Since a couple people have mentioned this, I confirm that I will leave the contest open until the final deadline, not closing it early. Then it will probably take a few days to review all entries before selecting a top proposal.
- 4 év telt el
1. Abdul1472
  - 4 év telt el
  Its better to leave feedback aswell so designers can improve their work. Will be submitting my entry soon
  - 4 év telt el
2. MAGICMACC
  - 4 év telt el
  Awesome!
  - 4 év telt el
A verseny kiírója:
- 4 év telt el
Please try find methods that do not require the discussion leader to know everything, nor spend too much time moderating user inputs.

If there are tens of thousands of users making suggestions, each user should not have to read all the suggestions from other users.
- 4 év telt el
1. MAGICMACC
  - 4 év telt el
  So maybe organizing the users through with a proper rating system and even a recent tab could be effective to organizing content for users. (maybe even more than upvotes or additionally?)
  - 4 év telt el
A verseny kiírója:
- 4 év telt el
Here are some considerations from individual proposals, that may be useful to all proposals.

James Surowiecki in Wisdom Of Crowds, states that users need to decide independently, to reach a good decision. On the other hand, most people think that a better decision requires that users get better information than what they started with. So that's a tough balance to make. Is there a way to preserve the information, without re-introducing the problems of "groupthink", and without taking up too much user time?
- 4 év telt el
1. MAGICMACC
  - 4 év telt el
  I love how your vision towards user logic is based, Def something to think about while constructing the wireframes and sections, Like the challenge! Thanks for the clarification.
  - 4 év telt el
CreativeKaif
- 4 év telt el
Working, will submit before the deadline
- 4 év telt el
SrinivasUi
- 4 év telt el
Greeting sir, just saw the contest and now i'm working on it please wait for my entry don't close the contest
- 4 év telt el
jaiambe
- 4 év telt el
Please see entry #24 and let me know your thoughts. Thanks
- 4 év telt el
A verseny kiírója:
- 4 év telt el
To clarify, I'm interested in solutions that redesign the decision & voting methods. Just restyling the example website is not what I'm looking for.
- 4 év telt el
1. KreateKat
  - 4 év telt el
  Would appreciate your feedback on my latest entry :)
  - 4 év telt el
sirajkhan1992
- 4 év telt el
#13 #14 please check and provide feedback
- 4 év telt el
omrfyyz
- 4 év telt el
Hey. Can you provide feedback for both my entry and every other freelancer's entry? This way we can make the UX you want.
Thank you in advance.
- 4 év telt el
1. A verseny kiírója:
  - 4 év telt el
  I am leaving feedback on most entries as they come in, usually within a day.
  - 4 év telt el
KreateKat
- 4 év telt el
Just submitted #12 . Would appreciate your thoughts on this, while I still have time to upload revisions.

Take care & be safe.
- 4 év telt el
Vehement
- 4 év telt el
Please check comments on #10
- 4 év telt el
KreateKat
- 4 év telt el
Will be submitting very soon. Please do not close the contest before time.
- 4 év telt el